The questions have been answered.
- The key leader lawyer Thio Su Mien has revealed herself.
- The internal liaising person which contacted Josie Lau is Claire Nazir. (Is Josie Lau’s statement an “arrow”?)
- The reason behind the take-over is due to signs of pro-homosexual.
- (Updated 25 Apr 2009: Old guard members counter allegations of a pro-gay stance)
- (Updated 29 Apr 2009: MOE reply on AWARE’s Sexuality Education Program in School)
Point 1: Quoting Straits Times,
“SENIOR lawyer Thio Su Mien on Thursday revealed the key role she played in bringing about the change of leadership at the Association of Women for Action and Research (Aware).
Appearing at a press conference called at short notice by some of the association’s new leaders, she said she was alarmed to discover that Aware had lost sight of its original purpose and become pro-lesbian and pro-homosexual.”
…
“Disturbed by what she saw as signs that it was promoting lesbianism and homosexuality, she began urging women she knew to challenge Aware’s attempts to redefine marriage and families.”
Point 2: Quoting the press conference by Thio Su Mien,
Josie Lau explains how Dr Thio helped get her involved:
“Let me share with you my story. I’ve been married to the family for 20 yrs. We meet occasionally once or twice a year, during Christmas and Chinese New Year. And she has been nagging me for the last 15, 20 years, asking “are you doing something in the public, contributing back to the community?”
…
“And when the opportunity came and she (Dr Thio) asked would you like to serve or join Aware, she said I’ll put you in touch with somebody. It was Claire Nazir who called me and she was looking for somebody to assist her in the area of marketing and that’s my area of expertise. And as it turned out, honestly, I did not join Aware thinking that there will definitely be a new exco. I just know that I’m joining aware & if I stand for election and got elected, this is the area where I think I can contribute.”
Point 3: In the press conference, lawyer Thio SM’s comments are as follows:
(1) ON AWARE’S SEXUALITY PROGRAMME
‘I started thinking, ‘Hey, parents, you better know what’s happening,’ she said. ‘I talked to parents. I said: You better do something about this, otherwise your daughter will come back and say, ‘Mum, I want to marry my girlfriend. Or your son will say: ‘Dad, I want to marry my boyfriend.”
These parents were flabbergasted, she said, adding that such sexuality education was taking place in the United States and Europe and was not new.
‘What is happening in society is that we are redefining marriage, we are redefining families,’ she said.
‘So I’m a concerned citizen and if people are so ignorant, I think I want to teach them.’
(2) AN ENTIRE GENERATION OF LESBIANS?
‘And this is something which should concern parents in Singapore. Are we going to have an entire generation of lesbians?’
Insisting that she was not anti-homosexual, she said: ‘I have nothing against lesbians or homosexuals personally. On a personal front, I’ve ministered, I’ve counselled them.
‘They are in pain. And very often from families where you have abusive fathers, they do things with their daughters and the daughters revolt, rebel against society.
‘We understand this is what it’s all about.’
(3) REFOCUSING ON ORIGINAL PURPOSE OF AWARE
‘I find to my dismay that Aware seems to be only very interested in lesbianism and the advancement of homosexuality, which is a man’s issue,’ she said. ‘Can we re-focus on the excellent objectives of Aware? Go back to its original purpose for it being an NGO?’ she asked.
Point 4: Quoting ST article “Old guard members counter allegations of a pro-gay stance”
AWARE’S old guard yesterday rejected the new leaders’ accusation that the association had become pro-lesbian and pro-homosexual. This was their response to the allegations made on Thursday.
PROMOTED A LESBIAN MOVIE
Aware sponsored the screening of the lesbian-themed movie, Spider Lilies, at its charity gala two years ago.
Former Aware president Constance Singam, 72: ‘Over the years some of the movies we have screened include Singapore Dreaming, Mrs Henderson Presents, The Soong Sisters, Summer Snow and Paradise Road.
We exercise our judgment. Earlier this year an Israeli Film, Seed Of Summer, was offered to us but we turned it down because the subject matter was sensitive and controversial - it dealt with military service and lesbianism.
Spider Lilies was about the relationship between a tattoo artist and a Web camera woman. One of my exco members - a mother of three boys - told me the two protagonists’ sexuality was secondary. It was a film about love, companionship and longing.’
HAD A MEN’S WORKSHOP
Aware invited Mr Bert Bjarland, a Finnish gender activist, to hold a workshop.
Male associate member Tan Wah Kiat, 37: ‘Bert Bjarland had spent 20 years working with men’s groups in Finland and wanted this issue tackled in Aware. His workshop helped men to recognise that there are many different masculinities.
We do not want to live in a box where men are supposed to be all macho, rough and aggressive; and women, soft, meek and domesticated.
I used to be a jock, and that is one of my biggest regrets. Joining Aware, I learnt the value of being soft and sensitive. I’ve been happily married for seven years. It really helps to build family and personal relationships.’
WANTS TO LET MEN VOTE
Former Aware president Dana Lam, 57: ‘We have been discussing this in Aware for years. We are a bit divided over this.
We women have been saying that decisions - public, personal, family - cannot be made by only men; that they have to be made jointly with men. If we walk the talk, then we have to give men the right to vote.
On the other hand, some of us feel we are not that ready to admit a male voice in the organisation. We are still debating this, and debate is healthy.’
MOTHER’S DAY 2006
Aware held an event featuring lesbian-friendly mothers and lesbian daughters talking about themselves.
Aware member Corinna Lim: ‘We had mothers with lesbian daughters coming together to share their pain and issues in a very supportive environment.
It was done in a loving way. How could they say it was bad when they didn’t even attend the forum? To me, that was love. The bond between a mother and child is precious, no matter what the circumstances.’
INVITED GAY ACTIVIST ALEX AU
Former Aware president Tan Joo Hymn, 38: ‘This forum, Playing It Safe: Keeping HIV At Bay, was organised because statistics showed that cases of women contracting Aids had shot up in Singapore.
Mr Au was one of four people at the forum; the others were a doctor, a representative from Action For Aids and then Aware president Braema Mathi.’
REACHING OUT TO TRANSVESTITES
Former Aware president Constance Singam, 72. ‘I’ve never talked about reaching out to transvestites in any newsletter.
Last year, I gave a talk to a lesbian audience and they asked me very tough questions and demanded to know why Aware was not fighting for their rights. I told them we were inclusive, but we could not lobby exclusively for lesbians.
The fact is, Aware represents all women. I told them we are also fighting for them when we fight for issues like equality, the right to personal choices and sexuality.’
WONG KIM HOH
Point 5: Quoting from MOE website,
“6 The schools that engaged AWARE found that the content and messages of the sessions conducted were appropriate for their students and adhered to guidelines to respect the values of different religious groups. The schools did not receive any negative feedback from students who attended the workshops and talks or their parents.
7 In particular, MOE has also not received any complaint from parents or Dr Thio Su Mien, who was reported to have made specific claims about sexuality education in our schools. MOE has contacted Dr Thio Su Mien to seek clarifications and facts to substantiate her claims.”